James is a lawyer whose solo law practice was drowning him — client meetings stacked back-to-back while his phone rang off the hook in the background. A seemingly good problem to have but he was leaving a lot of money on the table just because he couldn’t answer the phone.
He'd looked into hiring a receptionist, but balked at the $40,000+ annual price tag. Then, someone mentioned virtual receptionists and the various functions of virtual receptionists.
James isn't alone. Businesses across industries are abandoning traditional receptionists for virtual alternatives,
But with so many providers available, you need to understand what you're really getting — and paying for. The pricing models can be confusing, and providers don't exactly make it easy to understand what you're really paying for.
Let us walk you through what nobody else will tell you about virtual receptionist pricing.
The Financial Nightmare of Traditional Receptionists
Let's be brutally honest about what a traditional receptionist actually costs. The salary (Average of $40,764 nationally) is just the beginning of your financial commitment.
Here's what you're really on the hook for:
Base Salary: $36,000-$44,000
Health Insurance: $6,000-$8,000
Retirement Contributions: $1,800-$2,200
Paid Time Off: $2,800-$3,500
Payroll Taxes: $2,800-$3,400
And those costs swing wildly depending on location. In New York City, you'll pay between $35,000 to $44,000 annually, while in Clearwater, Florida you’ll pay between $22,000 to $30,000 annually.
But wait—there's more! The "hidden" costs nobody talks about:
That dedicated desk and computer setup? Not free.
Training costs never end.
Someone has to manage them.
Who answers when they're at lunch or sick?
Holiday coverage? Prepare to pay extra.
And let's not forget the extensive responsibilities of receptionists that they must fulfill—making it crucial to find the right person for the role.
The Three Virtual Receptionist Pricing Models (And Which One Is Trying to Rip You Off)
Let's cut through the marketing fluff and understand how these pricing models actually work. If you're curious about answering service costs, here's what you need to know.
But before that, it's important to distinguish between automated vs. virtual receptionist services, as they have different pricing structures.
Per-Minute Pricing: The Pay-As-You-Go Option
With per-minute pricing, you only pay for actual talk time.
This works beautifully if:
Your call volume jumps around like a jackrabbit
Your business is seasonal (think tax preparers or holiday retailers)
You're bootstrapping and need tight control over expenses
You're new and have no idea what your call patterns look like yet
But here's the secret providers won't tell you: how they count minutes matters enormously.
Every-second billing (like your cell phone): You pay for exactly what you use
30-second increments: A 31-second call costs you for 60 seconds
Full-minute increments: A 61-second call costs you for 2 full minutes!
That last option can inflate your bill by 30-40%. Always ask how they count.
Monthly Subscription Plans: The All-You-Can-Eat Buffet
Tiered pricing offers increasingly comprehensive packages at different price points. As you climb tiers, the per-minute rate often drops.
These work well for:
Growing businesses that need room to expand
Companies with somewhat predictable but variable call patterns
Businesses needing customizable service packages
High-volume users seeking bulk discounts
The catch? Complexity. You'll need a spreadsheet to figure out your actual costs.
The Price Tag Showdown: Who Charges What
Let's compare what the major players actually charge. Before deciding on hiring a receptionist, it's crucial to understand the cost differences between traditional and virtual receptionists.
Smith.ai
Base plan: $292.50 monthly for 30 calls
What makes them different: They've gone all-in on AI tools and live chat
Best for: Tech-savvy businesses that want modern integration with their other systems
Lead qualification ("Are you ready to buy, or just browsing?")
Order processing
Outbound calling
Multiple languages
Custom scripting
Dedicated team that gets to know your business
The Hidden Costs That Will Make You Curse
The monthly rate isn't the whole story. Here's where providers bury the fees they don't want you comparing.
Setup Fees
Most services hit you with $50-$200 setup fees. It's basically a "thanks for choosing us" tax. Always ask if it's negotiable — it often is.
The Billing Increment Scam
How they count minutes is the single biggest hidden cost multiplier:
6-second increments: Fair and reasonable
30-second increments: Sneaky but common
60-second increments: Daylight robbery
In plain English: A 3-minute and 10-second call costs you for 4 full minutes. That's a 25% markup on that call alone!
"Basic" Features That Suddenly Aren't Basic
Services you'd assume are included often come with mysterious fees:
Call transfers (shouldn't this be standard?)
Actually taking a message (seriously?)
Scheduling appointments
CRM integration
Mobile app access
It's like buying a car and discovering the steering wheel costs extra.
Premium Time Periods
Expect to pay more during:
After-hours ($50-$150 monthly premium)
Holidays (1.5x-2x normal rates)
Weekends (variable premium rates)
One provider I won't name charges triple rates on major holidays. Nothing says "Merry Christmas" like a surprise bill in January.
Language and Tech Upcharges
Need something beyond basic service?
Bilingual support: Additional $100-$200 monthly
CRM integration: Technology fees that vary wildly
Custom reporting: Data storage and reporting fees
Is This Actually Worth It? The ROI Breakdown
Let's get real about whether virtual receptionists deliver bang for your buck. When evaluating cost considerations, it's important to weigh both tangible and intangible factors.
The Actual Financial Benefits
If you're still on the fence, here are some compelling reasons for virtual receptionist services that can directly impact your bottom line:
Time Liberation: If three team members each spend an hour daily answering phones at $30/hour, that's $90 daily or $1,800 monthly they could spend on billable work instead.
After-Hours Business Capture: Virtual receptionists can increase lead conversion by 27% compared to sending callers to voicemail. How many $2,000 clients have you lost because they called at 5:15 PM?
Instant Response Value: Every minute a potential client waits reduces conversion probability by 4%. Think about that — a 10-minute delay cuts your chances by 40%.
Peak Handling: Virtual services can manage 300% more calls during rush periods without making you pay for that capacity during slow times.
The Stuff You Can't Put a Price On
Customer Experience: Nothing says "unprofessional" like a constantly ringing phone or calls going to voicemail during business hours.
Brand Perception: An always-available business feels more established, even if you're working from your kitchen table in pajama pants.
Stress Reduction: The constant interruption of phone calls is mentally exhausting. Removing that distraction is worth something.
Growth Support: As you grow, your virtual receptionist service scales with you—no hiring, firing, or training.
How to Decide If This Makes Sense for Your Business
By Business Size
Just you or a tiny team (1-5 people): Look at entry-level solutions costing $30-$100 monthly. You mainly need professional call handling and message delivery.
Small but growing (6-50 employees): Mid-tier options from $100-$300 monthly give you more features without breaking the bank.
Established business (51-250 employees): Solutions in the $300-$800 range provide the sophisticated features and integrations you need.
Large operation: Enterprise-grade solutions starting at $1,000+ monthly deliver customized handling and tight integration with your systems.
By Call Patterns
Here's how to figure out what you need:
Track your incoming calls for a few weeks. A simple spreadsheet works fine.
Note when your phone rings most - both time of day and days of the week.
How long are your typical calls? Five minutes? Ten?
What are people calling about? Simple questions or complex issues?
Where's your business headed? Will calls increase by 25% next year? 50%?
This data will tell you whether per-minute or subscription pricing makes more sense for your specific situation.
Traditional receptionist: $45,000-$55,000 base salary plus $15,000-$20,000 in benefits annually.
Virtual receptionist: $3,600-$6,000 annually for comparable service.
That's potentially a 40-60% reduction in what you're spending on answering the phone.
By Tech Stack
Consider how a virtual service will connect with your existing tools:
Using a CRM? Make sure your virtual receptionist can update it directly.
Need appointment scheduling? Confirm they can access your calendar system.
Have a phone system already? Check compatibility.
Use industry-specific software? Ask about integration capabilities.
The right connections can multiply the value you get from the service.
Make The Switch and Never Miss Another Call
Take a moment to consider: Is your current approach to answering phones helping or hurting your business? Could a virtual receptionist, with its flexible pricing models, give you both savings and growth?
The answer, for most businesses, is a resounding yes.
Book a free consultation with Smith.ai and discover how our AI Receptionist can help you capture and nurture your leads, be there for your business 24/7 and help you reach your business goals.
Maddy Martin is Smith.ai's SVP of Growth. Over the last 15 years, Maddy has built her expertise and reputation in small-business communications, lead conversion, email marketing, partnerships, and SEO.
Take the faster path to growth. Get Smith.ai today.