content hub
>
>

Full-time vs. Virtual Receptionists — Which Is Right for You?

By
Peter Wahlberg
Published 
2020-05-06
Updated 
2024-01-02

Full-time vs. Virtual Receptionists — Which Is Right for You?

2024-01-02

Clio's 2024 report found that law firms only answer 40% of incoming calls — a 28.6% decline from 2019. 

The traditional solution involves hiring full-time reception staff at approximately $4,400 per month, including salary and benefits. According to SHRM's 2025 research, first-year costs exceed $60,000 when including recruitment, onboarding, and training expenses.

Virtual receptionist services offer a lower-overhead alternative, handling call answering, lead qualification, and appointment scheduling through AI-powered systems, live agents, or hybrid models. 

Typical plans range from around $95 per month for low-volume AI plans up to $3,000+ per month for high-volume and 24/7 services.

What is a virtual receptionist?

A virtual receptionist is a remote call-handling service that manages incoming phone calls, qualifies leads, schedules appointments, and provides customer support without requiring physical office presence. These services operate through three distinct models:

AI Receptionist services use conversational AI, natural language processing, and automated systems to handle routine calls, answer frequently asked questions, schedule appointments, and collect caller information. 

These systems operate 24/7 without capacity limits, processing multiple simultaneous calls while maintaining consistent quality standards.

Virtual Receptionist services employ trained agents who handle calls that require human judgment, complex problem-solving, or relationship building. 

These professionals manage sensitive conversations, process payments, conduct detailed intake procedures, and provide personalized customer service that reflects your business standards.

Hybrid services combine both approaches, routing routine inquiries to AI systems while escalating complex situations to live agents. 

This architecture maximizes efficiency for straightforward calls while ensuring human expertise remains available when conversations require judgment, empathy, or specialized knowledge.

All three models integrate with existing business systems — CRM platforms, scheduling software, payment processors — automating data entry and workflow triggers that would otherwise require manual administrative work.

How much does a virtual receptionist cost?

Virtual receptionist costs range from $95 to $3,000+ monthly, depending on service type, call volume, and operational requirements.

  • AI Receptionist services typically cost $95-$800 per month. The AI Receptionist from Smith.ai starts at $95/month on the Starter plan for businesses with lower call volume. The Pro plan costs $800/month for higher call volumes.
  • Virtual Receptionist services with live agents range from $292.50 to $2,500+ monthly. Plans typically include defined call allowances with per-call overage charges. Entry-level plans handle lower call volumes, while professional tiers accommodate 300+ calls monthly.
  • Hybrid services combining AI and human capabilities cost $300-$3,000+ per month, depending on the distribution of calls between automated and live handling. These models route routine inquiries through AI systems while escalating complex conversations to trained agents.

Pricing structures vary significantly across providers. Per-call billing provides predictable costs regardless of conversation length, while per-minute pricing creates variable expenses based on call duration.

Factors affecting the cost of a virtual receptionist

Six operational variables determine virtual receptionist pricing, with each factor creating distinct cost implications depending on business requirements.

Call volume and peak times

Monthly call volume directly determines pricing tiers and overage charges. Businesses receiving 50 calls per month use entry-level pricing, while firms handling 300+ calls use professional-tier plans. If you exceed your plan's call volume, you simply pay for additional calls rather than getting bumped to a higher tier.

Service hours

Business-hours-only coverage (typically 8 AM-6 PM, Monday-Friday) costs significantly less than 24/7/365 availability. After-hours service, weekend coverage, and holiday availability each increase monthly fees.

AI vs human vs hybrid

AI Receptionist services cost 60-70% less than Virtual Receptionist services with live agents. AI systems handle routine inquiries, appointment scheduling, frequently asked questions, and basic information collection at lower per-call costs.

Virtual Receptionist services with trained agents offer human judgment, emotional intelligence, complex problem-solving, and relationship-building. These capabilities are essential for sensitive conversations, detailed intake procedures, payment processing, and situations that require adaptability.

Hybrid models combine both approaches, optimizing costs by routing calls appropriately.

Services included

Basic call answering and message taking cost less than comprehensive reception services. Advanced capabilities increase monthly fees:

Integrations and tech

Basic services operate as standalone systems requiring minimal technical configuration. Advanced integration with CRM platforms, practice management software, scheduling systems, and workflow automation tools increases the complexity of setup. Smith.ai offers connections to 7,000+ software platforms, including Salesforce, HubSpot, and Clio.

Setup, overage, and add-on fees

Setup fees, onboarding charges, and contract minimums vary across providers. Per-call billing creates predictable costs regardless of conversation length, while per-minute billing generates variable costs based on conversation duration.

How much does Smith.ai cost compared to the market?

Provider Service Type Example Entry Plan Billing Model
Smith.ai AI Receptionist + Virtual Receptionist AI: $95/month for 50 calls; Virtual: $292.50/month for 30 calls Per-call (base + overage)
Ruby Virtual Receptionist (live only) $309/month for 100 minutes, $1,369 for 500 minutes Per-minute bundles + overage
Nexa Virtual Receptionist (live only) $239/month for 100 minutes, $1,399 for 750 minutes Per-minute bundles + overage
Answering Service Care Virtual Receptionist (live) $179/month for 100 minutes, $599 for 500 minutes Subscription + per-minute overage
Frontdesk AI AI Receptionist only $65/month starting, $97+ for advanced workflows Flat monthly (AI)
Syntheia AI Receptionist only $9.99-$299.99/month by usage tier Flat monthly (AI)

Virtual receptionist cost vs full-time receptionist

The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that full-time receptionists earn an average annual salary of $36,000- $38,500. 

When factoring in employer costs for benefits, taxes, and insurance, total annual expenses typically range from $ 47,000 to $65,000+.

Beyond salary, businesses face recruitment challenges, onboarding time, training investments, and turnover risk. Administrative hiring takes weeks to complete, and new employees require time to reach full productivity. Turnover creates recurring costs as the cycle repeats.

Dimension Virtual Receptionist Full-Time Receptionist
Annual cost $3,600-$24,000 for most businesses $47,000-$65,000+ including salary, taxes, benefits
Coverage hours 24/7 or extended hours common; nights and weekends available Typically 9-5 weekdays; overtime costs for extended coverage
Scalability Easy to scale up or down with call volume; pay for usage Scaling requires hiring, training, and managing additional staff
Hiring and training None for the business; handled by the provider Recruiting, onboarding, training, and performance management are required
Reliability No sick days or vacations; provider handles redundancy Coverage gaps during PTO, illness, or turnover
Turnover risk Minimal; service continuity managed by vendor High impact when the receptionist quits; replacement costs apply
Technology Often includes call routing, CRM integration, and calendar sync Depends on internal tools; may require additional software spend
Quality of service Trained agents plus AI; scripts and workflows optimized over time Can be excellent, but consistency depends on individual performance
Flexibility Add channels like chat and SMS, multiple languages, and after-hours coverage easily Limited to what one person can handle during office hours
Best for Businesses wanting lower cost, 24/7 coverage, and scalability Offices needing physical front-desk presence for in-person tasks

Key cost differences

For most service and knowledge businesses, virtual receptionist services can save 70-90% compared to full-time reception staff while providing broader coverage.

In-house receptionists make sense when businesses truly need in-person tasks — sign-ins, physical mail handling, office coordination — at a specific location. 

For phone, chat, and lead handling alone, virtual models usually deliver better availability, lower cost, and easier scaling for growing teams.

One full-time employee provides single-shift coverage. After-hours calls, weekend inquiries, and holiday coverage create gaps. You could use a temporary answering service during coverage gaps, but this adds complexity and cost.

Hidden costs to watch out for (and how Smith.ai handles them)

Virtual receptionist pricing often includes fees beyond advertised monthly rates. Understanding these additional charges prevents budget surprises and enables accurate provider comparisons.

Set-up fees and onboarding charges

Many providers charge setup fees covering account configuration, system integration, and initial training. These one-time expenses add to first-month costs, though some providers waive setup fees for annual commitments or higher-tier plans.

How Smith.ai handles this: No setup fees or onboarding charges for any plan tier. Smith.ai provides white-glove setup, comprehensive onboarding with dedicated specialists, and wraparound account management.

Overage structures

Per-minute billing can lead to unpredictable costs when call duration exceeds expectations. Per-minute overage rates often exceed base plan rates by a significant margin.

Per-call pricing provides greater predictability but requires understanding call classification rules.

How Smith.ai handles this: Per-call billing structure with clear overage rates disclosed upfront. If you exceed your plan's call volume, you simply pay for additional calls rather than getting bumped to a higher tier.

After-hours and weekend surcharges

After-hours coverage frequently carries premium pricing. Providers may charge 20-50% surcharges for calls handled outside standard business hours.

How Smith.ai handles this: No surcharges for after-hours, weekend, or holiday coverage. 24/7 answering service included in all plans.

Bilingual support fees

Bilingual support often requires upgraded plans or per-call premiums. Spanish-speaking agent availability may add $50-$200 monthly or increase per-call rates.

How Smith.ai handles this: Bilingual English-Spanish support is included in all plans at no additional cost.

Technology and integration fees

Advanced features often require plan upgrades or add-on purchases. Detailed call analytics, CRM integration, appointment scheduling, and payment processing may cost additional monthly fees beyond base reception services.

Some providers charge per-integration fees for connecting to specific platforms.

How Smith.ai handles this: 7,000+ software integrations included, with no per-platform charges. A dedicated solutions team handles custom workflows using Zapier, Make, and more.

Contract terms and cancellation

Annual contracts typically offer lower monthly rates but create long-term financial commitments. Breaking these agreements may incur cancellation fees equal to the remaining contract value or 3-6 months of service charges.

How Smith.ai handles this: Month-to-month contracts with no long-term commitments or cancellation penalties. 30-day money-back guarantee eliminates risk for new customers.

How to choose the right virtual receptionist plan for your budget

Selecting optimal virtual receptionist service requires a systematic evaluation of call patterns, service requirements, and expected return on investment.

Calculate current call volume and missed opportunity costs

Review phone system analytics to determine average monthly call volume, peak period concentrations, and after-hours inquiry frequency. This baseline establishes minimum capacity requirements and identifies coverage gaps.

Determine optimal service model based on call complexity

Evaluate typical call characteristics to determine whether AI Receptionist, Virtual Receptionist, or hybrid services best match operational requirements.

AI Receptionist services handle routine inquiries effectively — appointment scheduling, frequently asked questions, basic information collection, and straightforward qualification protocols.

Virtual Receptionist services with trained agents manage complex interactions — including detailed intake procedures, sensitive conversations, payment processing, and situations that require empathy or adaptability.

Hybrid models optimize costs by routing calls appropriately.

Define required service hours and coverage expectations

Determine necessary availability based on customer expectations and competitive positioning. Consider whether you need business-hours-only coverage or 24/7 availability.

Evaluate billing model implications

Per-call billing provides consistent costs regardless of conversation length, benefiting businesses where calls vary significantly in duration.

Per-minute billing may cost less for very brief interactions, but creates budget unpredictability when customers need detailed discussions.

Test services before committing long-term

Select providers that offer month-to-month contracts and money-back guarantees, enabling a risk-free evaluation. Deploy services for 30-60 days while tracking performance metrics.

Get started with Smith.ai Virtual Receptionist

Virtual receptionist services eliminate the expensive annual cost of in-house reception staff while providing 24/7 coverage, professional call handling, and seamless integration with business systems.

Smith.ai offers both AI Receptionist and Virtual Receptionist services — individually or combined in hybrid models. Both services include spam call blocking, transparent per-call billing, and 30-day money-back guarantees.

Get started risk-free today to see how Smith.ai handles your business calls.

Written by Peter Wahlberg

Peter Wahlberg is the partner development manager at Smith.ai. He has over ten years experience in consultative sales, partner development, project management, and scaling teams and small businesses.

Take the faster path to growth.
Get Smith.ai today.

Affordable plans for every budget.

Take the faster path to growth.
Get Smith.ai today.

Affordable plans for every budget.
Definitions You Should Know
Glossary of Terms

Technical Implementation Terms

Voice user interface (VUl) design
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna allqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco labons.
Speech recognition integration
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna allqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco labons.
Text-to-speech optimization
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna allqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco labons.
API connectivity and webhooks
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna allqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco labons.
Real-time data synchronization
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna allqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco labons.